 |
| The US Capitol on January 6th |
“I know how you feel,” said President Donald J. Trump to the defeated crowd of rioters.
Today is the anniversary of the most shameful day in American history: January 6, 2021, when a horde of screaming, violent lunatics attacked the United States Capitol to stop the election count and certification of the votes that resulted in Joe Biden becoming the next president. Hours later, as the riot neared its unsuccessful end,
Trump emerged from hiding and briefly urged the ignorant insurgents to give up and go home. History has largely ignored that speech. Yet, we should not ignore it, for Trump’s own words devastated the ludicrous conspiracy theories, including his own conspiracy theories, which would soon follow.
Today, I make one simple point: Trump’s short speech totally refuted the leading January 6 conspiracy theories. Indeed, he refuted some of his own subsequent conspiracy theories. In fact, he noted - indeed, proudly admired - that the January 6 crowd insurrected against the United States on his own behalf, and he blessed them. They were not Democrats disguised as MAGA Republicans. They were not Antifa. They were not federal agents leading a “fedsurrection.”
The bizarre conspiracy theories spread in violation of all reason. It is time to put them down, not by quoting the mainstream media (which conspiracy theorists never trust), nor by checking facts (since, after all, conspiracy theories hold facts in contempt), but by quoting Trump’s exact words. Trump’s own statements destroyed the conspiracy theories.
Yes, January 6 conspiracy theories spread from the outset, angrily endorsed by top Republicans. Several Republican members of Congress, including Matt Gaetz, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Ron Johnson specifically questioned whether federal officials supported the January 6 riot, presumably to make Trump look bad. My own senator, Ted Cruz, said, “A lot of Americans are concerned that the federal government deliberately encouraged illegal and violent conduct on Jan. 6.” Representative Clay Higgins claimed that FBI agents were in the crowd, “inside the Capitol dressed as Trump supporters.” Social media pundits regularly castigate Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi for enabling the riot. Indeed, years later, Trump himself blamed the riot on Pelosi.
These absurd accusations resist endless refutation, but can they survive Trump’s own words? I don’t see how! So, let us remember Trump’s concluding speech that day! Let us look at his exact words.
First, in his mercifully brief but despicable speech, Trump not only identified with the conspiracy theorists but shared their suffering:
Finally, Trump, identified with the rioters’ false anger but acknowledged that the riot had been defeated and the protestors needed to go home:
Now, the people who falsely believe that the 2020 election was stolen will never learn, will never change, and will never accept reality. I can’t help them. Let us, nevertheless, notice that Trump himself knew that the rioters were on his side. Trump admired them. Trump said that he admired them. He said he loved them!
So, the rioters were not a hidden cabal of Nancy Pelosi supporters. Trump would never have loved them. This was not a cabal of federal agents who defied Trump’s authority as their president and demonstrated against his electoral defeat. Trump would not have loved them, either. These were Trump’s people, and Trump acknowledged them, and Trump shared their pain. Period.
To believe that the rioters were anyone other than Trump’s most fanatical supporters defies, not just logic, not just facts, but Trump’s own heartfelt words. Trump and his supporters can, and do, spread other lies to justify January 6, but this particular set of falsehoods collapses under Trump’s own language.
This was lucky for the cause of truth. In his brief, lie-filled speech, Trump could, ironically, not resist speaking from his true, albeit foul, heart. He loved the rioters, empathized with their fears, and sympathized with their goals. As it happens, confirmed liar that he was, Trump still could not resist telling the one central truth.
To overcome conspiracy theories poses a great challenge. Conspiracy theorists ignore fact-checkers and cling to their make-believe world like a seamy security blanket. They sneer at anyone who might question their narrative. They cannot, however, conceivably question the words of Donald Trump himself. By momentarily stating the truth, Trump dissipated an entire set of conspiracy theories. All we need to do is to remember what Trump said on that shameful day. From speech, a hidden truth. “We love you,” Trump said. “I know how you feel.”
Yes, January 6 conspiracy theories spread from the outset, angrily endorsed by top Republicans. Several Republican members of Congress, including Matt Gaetz, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Ron Johnson specifically questioned whether federal officials supported the January 6 riot, presumably to make Trump look bad. My own senator, Ted Cruz, said, “A lot of Americans are concerned that the federal government deliberately encouraged illegal and violent conduct on Jan. 6.” Representative Clay Higgins claimed that FBI agents were in the crowd, “inside the Capitol dressed as Trump supporters.” Social media pundits regularly castigate Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi for enabling the riot. Indeed, years later, Trump himself blamed the riot on Pelosi.
These absurd accusations resist endless refutation, but can they survive Trump’s own words? I don’t see how! So, let us remember Trump’s concluding speech that day! Let us look at his exact words.
First, in his mercifully brief but despicable speech, Trump not only identified with the conspiracy theorists but shared their suffering:
“I know your pain, I know you're hurt. We had an election that was stolen from us. It was a landslide election and everyone knows it, especially the other side.”
Trump continued by lying that “this was a fraudulent election.”
Second, Trump praised the rioters:“We love you. You're very special. You've seen what happens. You see the way others are treated that are so bad and so evil.”Trump would never have praised Antifa, nor would he have praised FBI agents who supposedly rioted against him. He praised the crowd because he knew they were his people. No other motive could explain his speech.
Finally, Trump, identified with the rioters’ false anger but acknowledged that the riot had been defeated and the protestors needed to go home:
“But you have to go home now. We have to have peace. We have to have law and order. We have to respect our great people in law and order. We don't want anybody hurt.”Finally, once again sympathizing with the rioters, Trump told them:
“I know how you feel, but go home, and go home in peace.”
 |
| Donald J. Trump |
Now, the people who falsely believe that the 2020 election was stolen will never learn, will never change, and will never accept reality. I can’t help them. Let us, nevertheless, notice that Trump himself knew that the rioters were on his side. Trump admired them. Trump said that he admired them. He said he loved them!
So, the rioters were not a hidden cabal of Nancy Pelosi supporters. Trump would never have loved them. This was not a cabal of federal agents who defied Trump’s authority as their president and demonstrated against his electoral defeat. Trump would not have loved them, either. These were Trump’s people, and Trump acknowledged them, and Trump shared their pain. Period.
To believe that the rioters were anyone other than Trump’s most fanatical supporters defies, not just logic, not just facts, but Trump’s own heartfelt words. Trump and his supporters can, and do, spread other lies to justify January 6, but this particular set of falsehoods collapses under Trump’s own language.
This was lucky for the cause of truth. In his brief, lie-filled speech, Trump could, ironically, not resist speaking from his true, albeit foul, heart. He loved the rioters, empathized with their fears, and sympathized with their goals. As it happens, confirmed liar that he was, Trump still could not resist telling the one central truth.
To overcome conspiracy theories poses a great challenge. Conspiracy theorists ignore fact-checkers and cling to their make-believe world like a seamy security blanket. They sneer at anyone who might question their narrative. They cannot, however, conceivably question the words of Donald Trump himself. By momentarily stating the truth, Trump dissipated an entire set of conspiracy theories. All we need to do is to remember what Trump said on that shameful day. From speech, a hidden truth. “We love you,” Trump said. “I know how you feel.”
Trump's First Speech of January 6, 2021: A "Firehose of Falsehood"
Liz Cheney and the Firehose of Truth: Using the Republicans' Text Messages Against Them
by William D. Harpine
For my other posts about January 6 rhetoric, search for "January 6" in the box at right.
Follow-up: After I posted this, I saw that the White House published a note that, indeed, repeated the same conspiracy theories that Trump carelessly discredited in his second January 6 speech. How shameless, and oh, how easily people forget!
Copyright © 2026 by William D. Harpine
Official 2025 Inaugural Portrait of Donald J. Trump, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Image of January 6 Capitol riot, by TapTheForwardAssist, Creative Commons License, via Wikimedia Commons
No comments:
Post a Comment