Showing posts with label deception. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deception. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

Donald Trump Created the "Illusion of Proof" in His April 13, 2020 Coronavirus Task Force Press Conference


Image: WhiteHouse.gov
When CBS correspondent Paula Reid asked President Donald Trump at yesterday’s Coronavirus Task Force Briefing what he accomplished in February after buying the nation time by restricting travel from China, he promised to give her a list. His exact words: “will give you a list.” Was a list  forthcoming? No, of course not.

Likewise, during the same event, when CNN correspondent Kaitlan Collins asked who told President Trump that he had “absolute authority” over when the economy reopens, he fussed and argued a bit, and said,  “You know what we're going to do? We're going to write up papers on this.” Has the paper been forthcoming? No, of course not. In fact, he backed off his foolish claim the next day.

Trump created the impression that he had solid research behind his claims. However, he had no evidence at all behind them. So, like a stage magician, he created the illusion that he could prove his silly statements. Crooked politicians have used this tactic for years. More than half a century ago, communication professor Barnet Baskerville, one of the great speech and debate scholars of his generation, wrote an important article about “The Illusion of Proof.” We all know what proof is, do we not? Proof occurs when a speaker gives facts, expert opinion, and reasons to support a position. Illusion occurs when we think we see something that was never real. Capable people give evidence. Stage magicians don't give evidence; instead, they create illusions. The illusion of proof occurs when a speaker makes it sound as if he or she is giving proof, but is giving no proof at all. It's fun to watch a stage magician create an illusion. It is dangerous when politicians create them.

The illusion of proof is different from when a speaker gives bad proof or makes bad arguments. The illusion of proof arises when the speaker makes it sound as if there is proof, even though there is no proof whatsoever. Baskerville’s example was Richard Nixon’s Checkers Speech, in which Nixon talked about evidence that his lawyers and accountants had prepared, but never actually said what that evidence was. We hear this kind of thing when people spread conspiracy theories: “just you wait, and we will soon see proof that President Obama forged his birth certificate.” Or: “just you wait, and we will soon see proof that China created the coronavirus in a biowarfare laboratory.”

All of that is nonsense. If you have proof, say what it is. If you don’t have proof, you can, if you are dishonest and sneaky enough, promise that the proof will come later. Or, if you are really nasty, you can say that you have evidence, but say that it is secret. The public should never let this trick fool them.

Let’s start with what Paula Reid asked. Here’s the entire exchange, courtesy of a Salon transcript. (I added the italics.):

"Reid: What did you do with that time that you bought? The argument is that you bought yourself some time. You didn't use it to prepare hospitals. You didn't use it to ramp up testing. Right now, nearly 20 million people are unemployed.

Trump: You're so disgraceful. It's so disgraceful the way you say that….

Reid: Tens of thousands of Americans are dead. How is … this rant supposed to make people feel confident in an unprecedented crisis?… What did your administration do in February for the time that your travel ban bought you?

Trump: A lot.

Reid: What?

Trump: A lot, and in fact, we'll give you a list…. We did a lot. Look, look, you know you're a fake."

So, what did President Trump do? “A lot,” he said. What specific things did he do? He said he would give her list. He then called her a “fake,” which is classic misdirection, a standard magician's method. (It was also an ill-mannered thing to say.) Seriously if Trump had done something, wouldn’t he remember? If he had actually done something, would he not want to brag about it right then and there? And, guess what, we still haven’t seen the alleged list. Trump created the illusion that he and his staff  had done a lot of work to provide evidence, but, in real life, there was no evidence of any kind.

He created the illusion of proof a second time. Does the president have unlimited authority? A large part of the briefing consisted of rambling and dissension over this question: “There is debate over what authority you have to order the country reopened.”

Collins refocused attention on this issue after Trump changed the subject:

"Collins: You said when someone is president of the United States, their authority is total. That is not true. Who told you that?

Trump: You know what we're going to do? We're going to write up papers on this.

Collins: Has any governor agreed that you have the authority to decide when their states …

Trump: I haven't asked anybody because. … You know why? Because I don't have to ….

Collins: But who told you the president has the total authority?

Trump: Enough!"

So, President Trump said something ridiculous: that the president has absolute authority. After other questioners had brought the subject up, Collins nailed it: “That is not true. Who told you that?”

Obviously, no qualified person had told him such a thing. Trump said that his staff – “we” – “were going to write up papers on this.” Incompetent though President Trump’s staff might be, he doesn’t employ anyone stupid enough as to think that the president has absolute authority over anything. Trump as much admitted it: “I haven’t asked anybody because.… You know why? Because I don’t have to…” Collins followed up: “who told you…?” Trump refused to answer: “Enough!”

Again, Trump created the illusion of proof. He said that “We are going to write up papers on this.” When he said that, he created the impression – an obviously false impression – that his staff had been working on the legal and constitutional issues and were prepared to produce a document about it. In real life, however, he talked with no one, no papers were forthcoming, and there was no constitutional or legal basis for what he said. There are no papers on the subject and there never will be a paper on the subject. It’s ridiculous. But the way Trump phrasef things created the illusion that actual research had been conducted.

The public would like to assume that the President of the United States has access to experts and research capabilities, and that he says things that have merit. Dream on. 

It’s one thing to present terrible arguments. I suppose everyone makes bad arguments occasionally. It’s something else, also bad, to make a controversial claim and give no evidence for it. The illusion of proof is something even worse: by using misdirection and spreading confusion, a speaker creates the impression that evidence exists and even says something about what the evidence is like, but the evidence doesn't exist. In some ways, it’s worse than lying: when Trump says things that are not true, that’s shameful. Trump said that he would produce "a list." He said that he would produce "papers." Of course, that was untrue. When he says that evidence exists and will be forthcoming, when, in fact, there is no evidence and no evidence will ever appear, the level of deception is even worse than mere lying.



Here is a complete video on C-SPAN of the press conference with a rough transcript. Please note that the official but sneaky White House transcript is incomplete, and it omits substantial chunks of the exchanges above. Baskerville's article is not readily available on the Internet, but a large library should be able to get you a copy. Here's the citation:  Barnet Baskerville, "The Illusion of Proof," Western Speech, 25 (1961): 236-242. The journal is now called Western Journal of Communication.

Saturday, March 21, 2020

Why Did Trump Attack Peter Alexander at the March 20, 2020 Coronavirus Press Conference?

Donald Trump, White House photo
We heard many points made at yesterday’s press conference with President Donald Trump’s Coronavirus Task Force, but most people are talking about the president’s belligerent response to an innocent question by NBC reporter Peter Alexander. What happened is that Trump set a trap for Alexander, but Alexander didn't fall into the trap and Trump ended up trapping himself instead.

In context, the exchange went like this:

“Q    I’ll just follow up.  Nearly 200 dead.  What do you say to Americans who are scared, though?  I guess, nearly 200 dead; 14,000 who are sick; millions, as you witness, who are scared right now.  What do you say to Americans who are watching you right now who are scared?

“THE PRESIDENT:  I say that you’re a terrible reporter.  That’s what I say. Go ahead.


“Q    Mr. President, the units that were just declared —


“THE PRESIDENT:  I think it’s a very nasty question, and I think it’s a very bad signal that you’re putting out to the American people.  The American people are looking for answers and they’re looking for hope.  And you’re doing sensationalism, and the same with NBC and “Con-cast.”  I don’t call it — I don’t call it “Comcast,” I call it “Con-cast.”


To all appearances, Alexander asked a softball question. During a crisis – which Trump himself declared to be an emergency – most presidents would leap for joy at the chance to reassure the public and assert national leadership. But not Trump! Instead, Trump lashed out. Trump didn't even seem to notice that his canned response talked about hope, which is exactly what Alexander asked about.

What was the result? The predictable people make predictable responses. The mainstream press defended Alexander. An article in Vanity Fair said that the exchange proved that Trump was a “sociopath.” In contrast, conservative pundit Brit Hume agreed with Trump that Alexander asked an unfair question. Hume tweeted that it was a “gotcha question” of the kind that “hack WH reporters have been asking for decades.” Even Hume, however, agreed that Trump could have taken advantage of the opportunity to reassure viewers.

So, what’s going on here? Trump's nasty response was actually an interesting, albeit unsuccessful, rhetorical-persuasive tactic. Here's how it worked:

1. Trump and the press have been slicing at one another for years. Trump takes this personally, and he was, contrary to appearances, not at all interested in the content of Alexander’s question. He was only interested in defending himself from the press. So, ...

2. ... Given Trump’s personality and track record, my best guess – and it’s only a guess – is that Trump planned the exchange to begin with! He seemed to do something similar in 2018 when he called on CNN's Jim Acosta to ask a question. Acosta asked a tough question and Trump lashed out at him. Trump even suspended Acosta's press pass. That was an obvious set up. Now, NBC News reporters have not been among Trump's biggest boosters, and he may well have called on Alexander for the sole purpose of insulting him. Trump was probably going to attack Alexander no matter what Alexander asked. He no doubt expected Alexander to ask a tough question, but Alexander didn’t. He asked an easy question, so Trump’s tactic backfired. Trump's tactic failed because he had no way to anticipate that Alexander would ask an innocent question, and he wasn't thinking fast enough to switch tactics on the spur of the moment.

3. In a larger context, the Republican Party and the press haven’t gotten along well in recent years. Sorry to sound like a fire-breathing liberal, but the Republican Party disconnected itself from factual reporting a long time ago. That’s why Republicans and Fox News get along so well. The basic Republican policies, which revolve around tax cuts for super-rich people, are not popular and there is no evidence that they’re wise. Since these policies do not accord with the facts, Republican politicians have two obvious choices: they can admit that their policies are bad, or they can deny the very existence of facts. The latter tactic, absurd though it sounds, has served them well. Never forget that Trump staffer Kellyanne Conway introduced the concept of “alternative facts” to the news world a few years ago. So, Trump wasn't just attacking Alexander: he was attacking the concept of news reporting. His tactic would have worked in the eyes of Fox News addicts everywhere if Alexander had followed the script and asked a nasty question.

Many years ago, Daniel J. Boorstin wrote about what he called the pseudo-event. A pseudo-event is something that occurs only so it can be reported in the news. Donald Trump's rallies are classic examples.

Maybe we could say that Trump's exchange with Alexander was a pseudo-mini event. Trump picked a fight for the sole purpose of fighting. He wanted to look tough. He wanted to stand up to the press. The press was making him look bad by asking questions about the coronavirus that Trump had no good answers for. It was, Trump seemed to think, time to take vengeance. It was too bad for Trump that Alexander didn't know his lines.

Never attribute a rhetorical tactic to stupidity if you can instead attribute it to malice.

Monday, March 16, 2020

Donald Trump Could Learn Something about Good Public Speaking from Public Relations People: Truth and the Coronavirus


Coronavirus, CDC
The press often complains that President Donald Trump has been treating the coronavirus-19 crisis as a public relations problem rather than a public health issue. For example, Nancy LeTourneau writes in the Washington Monthly that Trump is making  "an effort to treat the situation as a public relations issue rather than a public health crisis." I disagree. LeTourneau's complaint underestimates the thousands of ethical public relations professionals who serve the public honorably around the country. Pretty much everything the President has done contradicts basic public relations principles. Indeed, he and his administration are making everything even worse than it needs to be by engaging in poor public relations.

What is public relations? The Public Relations Society of America (PRSA) explains that "public relations is a strategic communication process that builds mutually beneficial relationships between organizations and their publics" (italics added).  The most basic insight of any public relations crisis communication strategy is that the truth always comes out. Although most managers – including President Donald Trump – turn futilely to denial, obfuscation, and cover-up as their major tools, the truth is that coverups are doomed to fail. We live in an open society, and a secret that is known by dozens or hundreds of people is no secret at all. The only question is whether the manager will control the release of information to serve the public, or, instead, let the damaging information trickle out over days, weeks, months, or years, repeatedly reminding public that the organization has fallen short. Good public relations means to tell the truth, always, without exceptions. The best way to control a problematic story is to release all the information quickly and accurately, thus turning one’s mistakes into a one-day story. This frees the organization to deal with the real-world problems and make things right. Every beginning public relations student learns this.

Nevertheless, President Trump is inventing nothing new. It was the cover-up, not the initial crime of burglary, that drove President Richard Nixon out of office. Bill Clinton thought that he could deny his sleazy affair with Monica Lewinsky. He was wrong.

By trying to deny obvious truths, President Trump follows in the long, sad tradition of business managers, university presidents, and politicians who destroy their credibility and damage their organizations by misleading the public. Sora Kim, Elizabeth Johnson Avery, and Ruthann W. Lariscy explained this when they reviewed the most common responses to crises in an article published in the Public Relations Review: “Despite its ineffectiveness, organizations seem to continuously engage in denial, regardless of their crisis circumstances.”

On February 23, 2020, Trump said that the coronavirus was "very much under control in this country." That  quickly turned out to be false, and coronavirus continued to spread. The Trump administration’s promise that a million tests would be available in early March proved to be vastly overstated. President Trump’s Oval Office speech of March 11, 2012 contained several inaccuracies that needed to be corrected immediately: for example, he falsely promised to suspend the “tremendous amount of trade and cargo but various other things as we get approval.” Speaking at the CDC on March 7, he falsely said that “Anybody right now and yesterday – anybody that needs a test gets a test. They’re there. The tests are there. The tests are beautiful. Anyone who wants a test can get a test.” This was not only wrong but ridiculous, and testing has still not ramped up.

President Trump at March 15 Coronavirus Briefing
On the one hand, yes, the world has gotten accustomed to Donald Trump speaking untruthfully. And, sadly, Trump’s most loyal supporters continue to believe even his silliest claims. On the other hand, the truth comes out almost as fast as Donald Trump can lie about it. The predictable result is that he spreads confusion, damages whatever credibility he has left, and complicates effective action to deal with the crisis. So, when the Trump administration promised yesterday, March 15, to have 1.9 million tests by the end of the week, who is going to believe it? Even if it turns out to be true?

Denial is the common theme behind all of Trump’s falsehoods. He tried for weeks to deny that the coronavirus would even be a problem for the United States. He denied that the virus could get past his immigration restrictions. He denied that there was a problem with testing. As usual, denial doesn’t work. Denial doesn’t work because the problem is real. Effective public relations techniques would require the Trump administration to confront the problem head-on, as quickly and energetically as possible. Even now, with the government slowly lumbering into belated action, the United States continues to fall behind what it needs to do. And that, my friends, creates the real public relations problem.

Unfortunately, President Trump has never placed competent public relations or public affairs personnel in high positions in the White House. Sean Spicer became a worldwide joke the minute he pretended that Trump’s inauguration crowd was the largest ever. Sarah Huckabee Sanders more subtle, but she moved out of her job as it became obvious that few people in the press were foolish enough to believe what she said.

Every good public relations professional understands that, although the client pays your salary, public relations is first and foremost a social science that serves the public. Wise organizational leaders know that communicating honestly and forthrightly is the best way to maintain a long-term positive image. Unfortunately, the Trump administration’s approach to the public has been far from wise.

The Public Relations Society of America’s code of ethics specifies that “We adhere to the highest standards of accuracy and truth in advancing the interests of those we represent and in communicating with the public.” In public relations, honesty is the best policy – indeed, in the long run, the only effective policy. If Trump and his administration want to get the crisis under control, the first thing they need to do is to tell the truth about absolutely everything, all at once, without making excuses, while laying out a credible plan to make things better. Unfortunately, it remains to be seen whether anyone in the Trump administration possesses the will to do so. Instead, President Trump suffered a case study in incompetent crisis communication.

Readers may want to check out PR professional Allison Schroeder’s excellent article on the PRSA website about public relations during the coronavirus outbreak. Her non-political article gives solid advice to businesses that need to communicate with stakeholders about the coronavirus. The United States government should take heed.
In the meantime, dear readers, please stay healthy. 
Images: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention