Showing posts with label campaign rhetoric. Show all posts
Showing posts with label campaign rhetoric. Show all posts

Monday, September 1, 2025

John F. Kennedy's 1960 Labor Day Speech

John F. Kennedy
“American labor has insisted upon, and won, the highest wages and best working conditions in the world.” 
So said future president John F. Kennedy on Labor Day in 1960, as he launched his successful campaign for president. Most Labor Day speeches are political, for the rights of workers raise political questions. John Kennedy transcended the nickel and dollar economic issues, which were important enough in themselves, and insisted that only organized labor could protect the United States of America’s democratic form of government.

In this speech, pointedly delivered at Cadillac Square in Detroit, home of the motor vehicle industry and its unionized workers, John Kennedy called the Dwight Eisenhower administration anti-labor. President Eisenhower was not running for reelection, but the Republican Party had nominated Eisenhower’s vice president, Richard Nixon, to be their candidate.

Blaming economic downturns on the administration, Kennedy asked his pro-labor crowd to separate pomposity from economic troubles:
“But not even the rose-colored glasses monotonously peddled by the present administration with Madison Avenue slogans can hide the problems. There have been two recessions within 7 years, and there are economists who believe a third is coming.”
Then, building to his theme, John Kennedy insisted that the labor union movement protected the United States from dictatorial rule. The labor union movement
Cadillac Square in 2022

protected, he said, the rights of working people:
“Collective bargaining has always been the bedrock of the American labor movement. I hope that you will continue to anchor your movement to this foundation. Free collective bargaining is good for the entire Nation. In my view, it is the only alternative to State regulation of wages and prices–a path which leads far down the grim road of totalitarianism.”
That slippery slope may seem overstated, but Kennedy, the future president, insisted that collective bargaining by labor unions protected, not only the United States’ economy, but, indeed, the entire political system. That is a bigger issue indeed:
“Those who would destroy or further limit the rights of organized labor - those who would cripple collective bargaining or prevent organization of the unorganized - do a disservice to the cause of democracy.”
Following a well-worn rhetorical path, speaking 75 years ago, Kennedy transcended the immediate issue. By calling organized labor the foundation of American government, Kennedy elevated the issue past the question of bargaining for wages.

Then, turning the tables on the Republicans, he complained about economic stagnation. He accused the Republicans of turning American prosperity into a political game:
“The administration has played politics with this issue–as well as with the minimum wage, health care for the aged, school construction, and housing programs.”
In his conclusion, on Labor Day in 1960, Kennedy raised his transcending argument to a spiritual level:
“In the crucial years ahead, organized labor will have much to contribute to the cause of democracy. May I say, then, God bless you in your efforts. May they be rewarded in the creation of a better world for all who seek freedom.”
We hear rhetoric like this all the time, although John Kennedy did an excellent job of it. Politicians say things like, We are not just talking about education! We are talking about the foundation of civilization, or We are not just talking about one church’s rights. No, we are talking about the entire First Amendment. And so forth.


On the one hand, transcending arguments boost a speech’s power. Transcending arguments give political policies an ideological context. On the other hand, transcending arguments obstruct our attempts to debate policy issues. We are no longer talking about whether we should raise the minimum wage, or whether a church has the right to violate health or building codes. Once the argument has transcended, we need to confront the ideology before we can discuss practical actions. When arguments transcend practical issues, the transcendence harms the already challenging need to discuss, debate, and compromise.

Nevertheless, was not John Kennedy prescient? In the years since, a series of conservative economic policies have, indeed, suppressed the minimum wage, limited workers’ rights, and reduced protections for collective bargaining. Kennedy stated a judgment between workers’ rights, compared with the rights of the people who conservatives call “job creators.” We are always tempted to say that our opponents are not merely wrong, but evil. However, when at that point, how do we work together? The political and economic conflict between workers and owners remains with us today. Are there any easy answers? I don’t see any.

Still, by staking himself to the labor movement, John Kennedy celebrated Labor Day in its inevitably political vein and began his successful march to the White House.

by William D. Harpine  

___________________

Personal Note:

Many thanks to the hard-working people whose labor makes America great. Fond memories of Grandfather Michael Feduska and Uncle Harry Waslo, who worked in Pennsylvania's steel mills, and Grandmother Anna Feduska, who raised chickens. Less fond memories of my own brief, long-ago employment collecting people's trash for $1.80 an hour. 

Happy Labor Day to all! 


Research Note:


Professor Suzanne McCorkle wrote brilliantly about transcending arguments in her 1980 article, “The Transcending Claim as a Strategy of Pseudo-Argument.” She posits that transcending arguments create the false impression that speakers have proven something when they have merely changed the issue, or that they have proven something more important than what they want their listeners to think. She makes a good point. Something to consider. Her article is behind a paywall, but a good library might find a copy for you.

Professor David Zarefsky offers a more positive view of transcendence in argument. His essay is a chapter in Topical Themes in Argumentation Theory: Twenty Exploratory Studies. If the book seems too expensive, you might find it in a large university library.

Copyright © 2025 by William D. Harpine


Image of John F. Kennedy: Official White House photo, public domain

Image of Bagley Fountain, Cadillac Square by w_lemay, Creative Commons License,

Monday, October 28, 2024

Goals Are Not Plans: The Sad Case of Donald Trump

Some voters want their candidates to have actual plans. Others don’t seem to care.

During his infamous October 27, 2024 Madison Square Garden rally, presidential candidate Donald Trump promised to excel at foreign affairs. However, he stated no plans, only goals:

“I will end the war in Ukraine, which would’ve never happened if I were president. I will stop the chaos in the Middle East and I will prevent World War III from happening.”

OK, great. We all want that.

But those are only goals. Where are the policies? How would Trump have prevented the Ukraine-Russia war? I’d love to know. How will he get peace? Will he force Russia to withdraw? Negotiate a settlement? If so, how? Will he just cut Ukraine off and let Russia massacre the survivors? If so, why?

How will he be the first leader in thousands of years to end the Middle East conflicts?

How will he stop the wars and end the chaos? What policies, what plans, could achieve those goals? Who knows? Trump has never said, not in this speech, not anywhere.

Where are the details? Yes, the details matter.

Audiences, when you hear a campaign promise, always ask, “how?” Never, ever put blind faith in any candidate. Never assume they have actual plans. Until proven otherwise, assume that they are spouting hot air. Always ask, at least to yourself, “how will you do that?”

Earlier Post: Critical Thinking on the Cheap 

We all want peace. Goals, however, are not plans. Leadership lies in the details. Public speeches always come down to the audience! Audiences, it is your fault, and yours alone, if you fail to insist on details. Critical thinking can be hard, but sometimes it is as simple as asking: how? 

Vote wisely, America.

by William D. Harpine  

____________

P.S. Thanks to rev.com, a transcript service, for preparing a text of Trump’s speech.

Copyright © 2024 by William D. Harpine

Sunday, October 27, 2024

Kamala Harris Said Trump Admired Hitler. Do Voters Care?

Kamala Harris
Wise speakers adapt to their audience: their listeners’ values, goals, fears, and ambitions. Effective public speaking begins with the audience. Always. Public speaking teachers have taught that for, literally, millennia. Why don’t politicians figure it out? Why doesn’t Kamala Harris figure it out?

Unfortunately, we see Kamala Harris repeating Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign mistakes. As we should recall, Clinton spent much of her campaign pointing out Trump’s association with and appeal to evil people. For example, she ran advertisements linking Trump’s agenda to the Ku Klux Klan’s agenda. That was pointless. Donald Trump’s supporters had long since made peace with the man’s deep moral flaws. After all, they had heard the Billy Bush tape, where Trump boasted about committing sexual assault: “I moved on her like a bi--h.” They knew that Trump’s crowd had chanted, “Hail, Trump” while flashing Nazi salutes. 

Clinton’s advertising campaign proved that Trump was evil. His supporters already knew that. Did they care?

Along the same lines as Hillary Clinton, at an October 24, 2024 campaign event in Clarkston, Georgia, Kamala Harris made a valid point that embodied a rhetorical mistake. She complained about Trump’s alleged admiration for Adolf Hitler. She said:

“In fact, just this week, America heard from John Kelly, a retired four-star Marine general, who was Trump’s White House chief of staff, who said that, as president, Trump praised Hitler — take a moment to think about what that means — that Trump said, quote, ‘Hitler did some good things’ —

“AUDIENCE: Booo —

“THE VICE PRESIDENT: — and that Trump wished he had generals like Hitler’s, who would be loyal to Trump and not to America’s Constitution.”

Although I do not have a particularly high opinion of John Kelly, I do trust him to tell the truth on matters like this. But what political difference do his claims make? Not much. That is because conservative voters have quit agonizing about Trump’s moral flaws.


John Kelly's Speech about Frederica Wilson: How to Lose Credibility, and Fast


The social sciences help us understand why. Linguist George Lakoff explains that liberal voters gravitate toward candidates who express a “nurturing mother” metaphor, while conservative voters are looking for a “strong father.” Candidates like Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris, or (although male) Joe Biden offered their supporters a nurturing mother metaphor: they offered a nation of justice, support, and goodness. Those qualities do not dominate conservative thinking.

Instead, Donald Trump offers power. He does not talk about bringing justice to immigrants: he talks about expelling them. He does not talk about fixing the immigration system; he talks about closing the border. He does not talk about reforming government; he talks about ripping it up. He calls the United States government “the Deep State.” That does not mean that all conservative voters prefer evil and disorder. That would not be true. What is true is that conservative voters want their leaders to protect them from real and imaginary dangers. That is why voters in North Dakota, more than a thousand miles from the Mexican border, treat immigration as issue number one.

So, Kamala Harris made Trump’s seeming admiration for Hitler into a central campaign point. Core Democratic voters, obviously, are offended. Conservatives, in contrast, ask, “so what?”

Do you want proof? According to recent polls, General Kelly’s revelations seem to have made little difference in this closely contested election. Some of Trump’s supporters, no doubt, think that a new Hitler would be great. The bulk of Trump’s supporters have found ways to rationalize Trump’s anti-American views, and there we are.

Trump’s voters simply rationalize his wickedness. That is why Kamala Harris cannot budge them by reminding them that Trump spreads evil ideas. They already know that. They have known that for years. “I’m not voting for a preacher,” they say, over and over, like a mantra. They complain that Kelly is a traitor, or that Democrats are big meanies. They can then swallow hard and accept that Trump admires Hitler.

What Trump’s supporters could never accept, however, would be that Trump is weak. (Do you remember when his crowd booed as Trump recommended vaccination?) If Harris wants to budge shaky Trump supporters, she needs to talk about his whining and equivocating. She needs to point out Trump’s weaknesses: his terrible presidential record on the economy, his griping about the election, his fear of electric boat batteries, and so forth. Those things show Trump to be weak. Trump’s supporters might care about those things.


Does Donald Trump Lead His Supporters, or Do His Supporters Lead Him? Oops, He Asked Them to Take a Vaccine.


People who value social justice already support Harris. People who fear Hitler’s reincarnation already support Harris. If she wants to pick up undecided voters, or to sway any of Trump’s less committed, supporters, Harris needs to focus on what they care about. What they care about is strength. And weak leaders terrify them. It is pointless for her to tell undecided voters that Trump is evil. She needs to show them that Trump is weak.

If a speaker wants to persuade people, it’s time to identify what the audience cares about. Nothing else matters.



Adolf Hitler’s “Christian Nationalist” Speech

by William D. Harpine
____________

PS: Is Trump another Hitler? Of course not. Hitler wrote his own book.


Copyright © 2024 by William D. Harpine

Image: Official White House photo, public domain

Sunday, July 16, 2023

Abraham Lincoln, White Supremacist, Part 2: The Fourth Lincoln-Douglas Debate

Abraham Lincoln
On September 18, 1858 during the fourth Lincoln-Douglas debate in Charleston, Illinois, future president Abraham Lincoln declared:
“I as much as any other man, am in favor of the superior position being assigned to the white man.”
Yes, Lincoln favored white supremacy, that is, he stated both that White people should be in charge, and that White people were superior in nature to Black people.

Yesterday, browsing on social media, I stirred up a bit of dissension when I commented that Abraham Lincoln, our greatest president, was a white supremacist. I would think that anyone familiar with the United States history would have known that. Lincoln certainly disliked slavery; however, as he rose to political prominence, he equally opposed racial equality. His seven debates against Stephen Douglas during their 1858 campaign for Illinois senator made him the leading moderately anti-slavery candidate. So, today, let us look carefully at the fourth Lincoln-Douglas debate to clarify Lincoln’s opinion about racial equality.

Earlier Post: Abraham Lincoln, White Supremacist: The First Lincoln-Douglas Debate

Lincoln was a creature of his time. His views were politic, and he could never have been elected president in 1860 if he openly favored abolition. The abolition of slavery was, at that time, considered to be a radical policy. Those are important matters, but they do not refute the simple reality that Lincoln favored white supremacy as a matter of public policy, and I don’t understand
Lincoln Memorial

why that causes so much controversy. Nor is the issue outdated. Consider that members of Lincoln’s party, the Republican Party, sometimes today advocate some version of white supremacy themselves. Nor do we, citizens of the United States, do ourselves any favor if we whitewash our past, or if we elevate Abraham Lincoln, our greatest president, into some kind of pristine demigod, remembered only as a larger-than-life statue of a marble man on a pedestal. 

With that said, I hold, as a modern white son of the South, that chattel slavery and all of the other cruel forms of forced labor are and always have been wicked, and that white supremacy is a foul philosophy. Readers who think otherwise will have little interest in the rest of this post. 


Lincoln Opposed Racial Equality

During their 1858 campaign, Douglas positioned himself as the pro-slavery candidate, while Lincoln held that slavery was evil and should not spread to any of the new states that were gradually being admitted to the Union. Lincoln carefully promised not to interfere with slavery where it already existed. This was, overall, considered a liberal position. 

For example, during this fourth debate, Lincoln specifically said that the White and Black races should not be equal, and that he certainly did not intend for Black people to have the right to vote. It was also his policy to keep juries all-white, to keep Black people out of public office, and to outlaw racially mixed marriages. He stated these points at the long debate’s outset:
“I will say then that I am not, nor ever have been, in favor of bringing about in any way the social and political equality of the white and black races, [applause]-that I am not nor ever have been in favor of making voters or jurors of negroes, nor of qualifying them to hold office, nor to intermarry with white people.”
Interesting, is it not, that the reporters noted that Lincoln’s brazenly racist comment received the audience’s applause? Yes, the assembled crowd evidently enjoyed Lincoln’s white supremacist opinions. Indeed, one wonders whether they were relieved to hear that Lincoln, although a liberal, nevertheless supported white supremacy. Evidently, even in a free state like Illinois, only a white supremacist could hope to win an election.

Lest we think that Lincoln’s views should be relegated to the 19th Century, let us remember that not until the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, both adopted only in my own lifetime, 100 years after the Civil War, did the United States government take a firm stand against white supremacy and racial subjugation. What explanations, however, made Lincoln feel that white supremacy was acceptable?


Lincoln Stated that Black People Were Inferior

And, indeed, white supremacy obviously required some kind of moral justification. The standard explanation that White racists gave in the 1800s was that, according to White racists, Black people were simply not as good as White people. Lincoln baldly endorsed that view in this debate. In fact, Lincoln continued that the supposed inferiority of Black people required that Black people remain in a subordinate position:
“And I will say in addition to this that there is a physical difference between the white and black races which I believe will forever forbid the two races living together on terms of social and political equality. And inasmuch as they cannot so live, while they do remain together there must be the position of superior and inferior, and I as much as any other man am in favor of having the superior position assigned to the white race.” [italics added]

So, was Lincoln a white supremacist? That statement removed all uncertainty.  


Earlier Post: Rev. Henry J. van Dyke, Sr. and the pro-Slavery Rhetoric of the Christian Right, Civil War Style


Lincoln Was a Sympathetic White Supremacist

Nevertheless, Lincoln did advocate some level of civil rights for African Americans. That, no doubt, must have shocked some of his audience. First, he did say that African Americans should have a degree of liberty:
“I say upon this occasion I do not perceive that because the white man is to have the superior position the negro should be denied every thing.”
Then, much to his audience’s delight, he immediately turned that noble assurance into a tasteless joke. Maybe he wanted to soften the shock. His joke, in turn, helped him to restate that he opposed racial equality:
“I do not understand that because I do not want a negro woman for a slave I must necessarily want her for a wife. [Cheers and laughter.] My understanding is that I can just let her alone. I am now in my fiftieth year, and I certainly never have had a black woman for either a slave or a wife. So it seems to me quite possible for us to get along without making either slaves or wives of negroes. I will add to this that I have never seen, to my knowledge, a man, woman or child who was in favor of producing a perfect equality, social and political, between negroes and white men.”
So, there we go. Abraham Lincoln, a sympathetic, jovial, good-hearted racial supremacist.


Conclusion

In no way do I demean Lincoln’s dramatic accomplishments as president. Although he lost the 1858 senatorial election, he was elected to be President of the United States in 1860, taking office in March 1861. He preserved our union, assets and faults and all. He led the nation through the Civil War’s horrors, signed the Emancipation Proclamation, and was eventually martyred for his anti-slavery views. His legacy endures in his speeches: his pre-Civil War speeches were models of careful reasoning and audience adaptation, while some of the speeches that he gave during the Civil War are inspiring landmarks of American thought and eloquence.

Earlier Post: Abraham Lincoln and the Definition of “Liberty:” A Lesson for Our Time

Earlier Post: A White Supremacist Spoke from the Steps of the Lincoln Memorial

Also, let’s not forget that, when we call Lincoln a creature of his times, we inevitably ignore the fact that political public opinion in the United States of America was, at that time, only the public opinion of White people. Slaves struggling under the cruel lash obviously had no vote and little public voice. Even in the north, many free states still denied African Americans the right to vote. Lincoln adapted to his audience by expressing racist views. That does not mean that the entire nation was racist. It means that many people who had power were racists. Furthermore, the fact that Lincoln was elected to the presidency in 1860 shows, obviously enough, that anti-slavery sentiment was spreading in large parts of the country.

So, when we ask whether it is fair to judge Lincoln by 21st Century standards, let us remember that a great many people in 1858 already knew that slavery and racial oppression were wicked.

If circumstances allow, I hope to write more about Lincoln’s speeches, as he is justly admired as the United States’ greatest orator. We can and should admire the man; we must, however, equally remember the horrors that swirled around him.

Nor should we underestimate those horrors. The Civil War started three short years after the Lincoln-Douglas debates. That brutal conflict took almost as many American lives as the American Revolution, the War of 1812, the Mexican War, the Spanish American War, World War I, World War II, the Korean conflict, the Vietnam War, and the war against terror added together. If slavery was the United States’ original sin, the penance was terrible. Nor is the penance complete. Its reverberations continue to echo through our society today. We gamble on a losing hand when we forget the past.

________________

P.S. I’m sure we all noticed that Lincoln favored putting “the white man” in charge, with, of course, no recognition of women. We’ll reserve that important issue for another day.

Note on the text: There were no sound recording devices in 1858; the texts of these debates were produced by skilled shorthand reporters. They are probably as accurate as such a method can be, but errors would be inevitable. These texts were printed in newspapers across the country, reaching a far larger audience than the 12,000 people estimated to have heard Lincoln and Douglas debate on that day. 



Photo of Abraham Lincoln, 1863, Moses Parker Rice, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Photo of Lincoln statue, National Park Service