Showing posts with label rhetoric of tradition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rhetoric of tradition. Show all posts

Sunday, August 25, 2024

Kamala Harris 2024 Convention Speech: Tradition and Progress

Kamala Harris
“We are,” said Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris in her August 22, 2024 acceptance speech at the Democratic National Convention, “the heirs to the greatest democracy in the history of the world.” Harris’ liberal policies emerged from an ideology of constitutional tradition. Harris gathered her progressive policies and grounded them in a tight net of conservative values. Like many liberal speakers before her, Harris called on the United States of America to live by its traditional values, such as freedom, opportunity, and dignity. 

People do not remember presidential nomination acceptance speeches for the policies that they mention. No, it is the speaker’s values that resonate. 

In contrast to the conservative view, however, Harris’ tradition pointed to a positive future, a future in which we all can triumph, while some conservatives cling tenaciously to a past that never really existed. The progressive idea of tradition echoes from the Declaration of Independence, stating that we are all equal, but there is also a tradition which holds (to paraphrase George Orwell), that some people are more equal than others. Tradition’s duality resonates throughout our history. 


Harris Rejected Zero-Sum Politics

Politics often seems like a game, in which some people win while others lose. Should we put the tax burden on working people, or soak the rich? Do we support immigration or reject immigrants? Do we give minority people a chance? Or do we fear and reject them? Harris rejected that entire attitude.

Those of us who study political discourse know that voters only pretend to vote based on issues. Values drive the voters. So, Harris spoke for: 
“An America, where we care for one another, look out for one another, and recognize that we have so much more in common than what separates us.” 
Harris went so far as to accuse conservatives of running down the nation that they claim to praise:
“… none of us has to fail for all of us to succeed. … in unity, there is strength. Our opponents in this race are out there every day, denigrating America, talking about how terrible everything is. Well, my mother had another lesson she used to teach. Never let anyone tell you who you are. You show them who you are. America, let us show each other and the world, who we are and what we stand for: freedom, opportunity, compassion, dignity, fairness, and endless possibilities.”

“In unity, there is strength,” she said, and that unity was found in traditional values like “freedom, opportunity . . . and endless possibilities.”


Harris Spoke for Liberty and Equality

Continuing, Harris reminded her cheering crowd that the United States’ basic values are “freedom and liberty,” and that we must look forward to a growing future:
“... on behalf of our children and our grandchildren, and all of those who sacrificed so dearly for our freedom and liberty, we must be worthy of this moment.”
“Heirs,” she said: we have an inheritance to preserve. “Our children and our grandchildren,” who should share that inheritance – in the future. Although many people reflect fondly about the wonderful past, Harris asked us to look forward. But she did not ask us to look forward with blindness. Instead, she said to let the founding values guide us toward an even better future:
“It is now our turn to do what generations before us have done, guided by optimism and faith to fight for this country we love, to fight for the ideals we cherish, and to uphold the awesome responsibility that comes with the greatest privilege on earth: the privilege and pride of being an American.
“So let’s get out there. Let’s fight for it. Let’s get out there. Let’s vote for it. And together, let us write the next great chapter in the most extraordinary story ever told. Thank you. God bless you and may God bless the United States of America.”
Harris looked hopefully toward a better future: “the next great chapter.” In contrast, her opponent Donald Trump preaches: “Make America Great Again.” Make America great again is the motto of someone who thinks America’s greatness rests in the past, while Harris’ “the next great chapter” says that the greatest days lie ahead. Despair versus hope. Look backwards for guidance, but to the future with confidence?

So, Harris came back to the starting point! Her traditional values lead to the future. Trump’s traditionalist anxiety, she implied, leads into the past – to restore what we he thinks we once had.

If we stay mired in the 18th century clinging to the past, as Trump calls us to do, equality for all is lost, abandoned. The United States of America’s founding values created a vision of a new kind of nation – “conceived in liberty,” said Abraham Lincoln. If Harris is right – and I think she is – we should let our values, not our fears, move us forward to face our problems and improve our lives. 

For, contrary to her critics, Harris’ speech did not reject the values of United States of America's founders. She embraced those values. She called for the United States to choose those values – freedom, opportunity, and equality. She argued that those values would determine, not only the election, but the United States’ future. She offered an idealistic vision for our cynical age. Harris presented her candidacy as a chance to remember the old values.



Research note: the argument from tradition is more helpful than many people realize. I’ve written about tradition in some of my academic publications; check the link to “William D. Harpine’s Publications” above. Readers might also want to look at James Darsey’s prize-winning book, The Prophetic Tradition and Radical Rhetoric in America. Darsey argues that radical speakers often tie their policies to tradition by quoting the Hebrew prophets. Also see a superb prize-winning monograph, The American Ideology: Reflections of the Revolution in American Rhetoric, by my mentor Kurt W. Ritter and his colleague James R. Andrews, which shows how the ideologies of freedom and liberty have permeated American rhetoric throughout history. Although it is out of print, most large research libraries should have it on their shelves, and don't forget about used bookstores.  

Special thanks to rev.com, a commercial transcript service, for preparing quick and accurate transcripts of this and many other public speeches. 


Copyright © 2024 by William D. Harpine

Image of Kamala Harris: official White House photo, public domain

Tuesday, May 30, 2023

Kamala Harris' Speech at West Point: Tradition and Innovation

Kamala Harris
For the first time in history, a woman gave the commencement address to the graduates of the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York. On May 27, 2023, Vice President Kamala Harris spoke to congratulate the cadets. For the most part, her speech was conventional and safe, but she did take time to celebrate the increasing role of women in the United States military. Like a long line of liberal speakers before her, she (paradoxically) located innovation in the firm service of tradition. The tradition was the tradition of innovation, and, yet, innovation is, of course, the opposite of tradition.

So, Harris commented that:
“So, to the Class of 2023 and to all the cadets here today: You stand on the broad shoulders of generations of Americans who have worn the uniform, including many barrier breakers and trailblazerss.”
When she said, “generations of Americans,” she emphasized tradition. When, in her next breath, she talked about “barrier breakers and trailblazers,” her point was innovation. Breaking barriers. Blazing new trails.

She continued that theme a moment later, reminding the cadets that:
“In fact, this year, you celebrate the 75th anniversary of the integration of women in the military, as well as the desegregation of our military. (Applause.)”
So, once again, she combined tradition (75th anniversary) with an integration policy that many conservatives would still consider to be innovative.

Harris concluded that section by addressing what she called a “fundamental truth:” 
“Our military is strongest when it fully reflects the people of America.”
Harris speaks at West Point 

Harris took time to congratulate Cadet Mary Bell, whose mother was also a West Point graduate, and Cadets Aaron Hall and Claire Dworsky, whom she had nominated to West Point when Harris was a United States Senator. She didn’t need to remind the audience that the Bells and Dworsky were women. Listeners could draw the link for themselves.

Bringing women and minorities into a complete role in the military has represented a dramatic, although gradual, change in the military forces. Tradition and “fundamental truth” are, however, conservative watchwords: the paradox of traditional innovation.

Harris’ persuasive tactic was to imply that innovation is traditional. It's unclear to me that this argument has ever convinced any conservative. It does, however, recast innovation into a new context. The argument from tradition asks conservative listeners to think about whether they should, or should not, live up to the fundamental principles of equality and liberty that most of them espouse.

Finally, although she didn't say so, the fact that it was Harris - a minority woman - giving the speech gave living proof to the growing role of women in the American polity. Good for her.


Kamala Harris Acceptance Speech at the Virtual DNC Convention: Breaking Ground with Caution

Oprah Winfrey's Eulogy for Rosa Parks: A Speech about Opposing Traditions

President Macron's Speech to Congress: Reminding the USA of Its Traditions

_______________

P.S.: Conservatives promptly jumped on social media to claim that conservative firebrand author Ayn Rand gave the 1974 commencement speech at West Point. That is incorrect. Rand did make a brief 1974 appearance at West Point, but she was not the commencement speaker. Howard H. Callaway was the 1974 West Point Commencement Speaker.

Also, while we're at it, the United States Military Academy campus is a gorgeous architectural wonder on the banks of the Hudson River palisades. Visit if you get the chance. It’s worth the drive. 

Research Note: Harris’ tactic has a long tradition! For example, in his award-winning book The Prophetic Tradition and Radical Rhetoric in America, Professor James Darsey points out that progressive speakers often quote the Hebrew prophets.

Images: Official White House photo, White House YouTube Channel    


Sunday, March 27, 2022

Ketanji Brown Jackson, a Progressive Traditionalist. Will We Live up to Our Values?

Ketanji Brown Jackson
At her confirmation hearing last week, Republicans painted Ketanji Brown Jackson as a leftist radical. Yet, her opening statement was all about tradition. She talked about what she called the “grand experiment of American democracy.” If confirmed, Jackson will be the first African American woman on the United States Supreme Court. Her opening statement was both traditional and innovative – a paradox. Progressive traditionalism is actually a common trope in progressive rhetoric, let’s look at how it works. Let us look at how Jackson’s opening statement reconciled the Revolutionary War tradition of equality with the heritage of the Civil Rights Movement.

Ever since the nation’s founding, contradictory ideologies have struggled for the nation’s soul. We have, of course, the Declaration of Independence’s timeless statement, penned by Thomas Jefferson, that we are all equal:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.”

Despite his magnificent words, Jefferson owned three plantations operated by slave labor. Indeed, chattel slavery – one of the world’s most wicked institutions – was widely practiced among the 13 colonies. It took the Civil War to end legalized slavery. Jim Crow, de facto segregation, and voter suppression never completely died out. Yet, it was the government that finally passed legislation “to secure these rights” during the Civil Rights movement.

Much progressive rhetoric hearkens back to Jefferson’s idealistic vision. Equality and equal justice are ancient American traditions. Against massive conservative opposition, the 13th Amendment to the Constitution ended slavery, the 14th Amendment guarantees equal protection of the law, and the 15th amendment protects the right to vote. Civil Rights legislation passed in the 1960s. Having been in force for decades, have they now become part of the United States’ traditions? Or do Civil Rights continue to be part of what Republicans call a “radical leftist agenda.”


Judge Jackson Memorialized Civil Rights

So, what did Jackson say about tradition? After thanking her family, friends, and mentors, Jackson praised the United States’ blessings. She did not, however, tie those blessings to 1776. Instead, she tied them to the more recent heritage of Civil Rights. In other words, she argued from tradition, but not the tradition that the Republican senators most wanted to hear. As she praised the United States, Jackson also reminded the audience that her parents enjoyed freedom because of the Civil Rights legislation of the 1960s.

“The first of my many blessings is the fact that I was born in this great Nation, a little over 50 years ago, in September of 1970. Congress had enacted two Civil Rights Acts in the decade before, and like so many who had experienced lawful racial segregation first-hand, my parents, Johnny and Ellery Brown, left their hometown of Miami, Florida and came to Washington D.C. to experience new freedom.”

A key phrase: “new freedom.” Not the old freedom of 1776, which didn’t include everyone. A new freedom. Although the Revolutionary War purported to give all Americans liberty, Jackson’s parents only enjoyed “new freedom” because of the Civil Rights Movement and the chance to relocate.


Jackson and the Ideal of Equal Justice

Values, like liberty and equality, force us to question our actions. Will we let our values change our behavior? Will we become better people by following our values? Or will our values only get lip service? Jackson tied her love of country to a new tradition – a “new freedom” – the tradition of African-American success:

“During this hearing, I hope that you will see how much I love our country and the Constitution, and the rights that make us free. I stand on the shoulders of many who have come before me, including Judge Constance Baker Motley, who was the first African American woman to be appointed to the federal bench and with whom I share a birthday.”

Will the nation live up to its ideals? Jackson addressed that question as well:

“And like Judge Motley, I have dedicated my career to ensuring that the words engraved on the front of the Supreme Court building—"Equal Justice Under Law" — are a reality and not just an ideal. Thank you for this historic chance to join the highest Court, to work with brilliant colleagues, to inspire future generations, and to ensure liberty and justice for all.”


Conclusion

“To ensure liberty and justice for all.” That is an ideal. Yet slavery, Jim Crow, and voter suppression have been realities. We create ideals because we want to improve ourselves. Jackson’s opening statement talked a lot about tradition, but the traditions became complex because the United States is a complex nation. We are all, Jefferson insisted, “created equal.” Our rights are, he said, “unalienable.”

Those traditions go back to the nation’s founding. Racial discrimination also goes back to the nation’s founding. And, yet, Civil Rights legislation dates back more than 50 years. Jackson melded those traditions.

So, are we ready to continue with “new freedom?” New freedom from traditional values? Like many progressive speakers before her, Jackson insisted that progressive ideas grew from traditional roots.


_________________

Earlier Post: Could Ketanji Brown Jackson Have Reset the Republicans' Agenda?

Earlier Post: Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer's Retirement Speech Reminded Us That the United States Is an Experiment

Earlier Post: Oprah Winfrey's Eulogy for Rosa Parks: A Speech about Opposing Traditions